SFAR Madhya Pradesh 2024-25
State Finances Audit Report
Government of Madhya Pradesh
This chapter reviews Madhya Pradesh budgetary process, revealing significant gaps between budget estimates and actual expenditure, with issues like excess spending, persistent savings, and last-minute fund surrenders. It highlights weaknesses in financial planning, control, and compliance, stressing the need for realistic budgeting, timely fund utilisation, and modern practices like gender, agriculture and child budgeting.
In compliance with Article 202 of the Constitution of India, in respect of every financial year, a statement of the estimated receipts and expenditure of the State for that year, called "the Annual Financial Statement (Budget)" is to be laid before the State Legislature. The estimates of the expenditure show 'charged' and 'voted' items 26 of expenditure separately and distinguish expenditure on revenue accounts from other expenditure. Legislative authorization is necessary before incurring any expenditure by the State Government.
As per the Madhya Pradesh Budget Manual, the Finance Department is responsible for preparing the annual budget by obtaining estimates from various departments. The departmental estimates of receipts and expenditure are prepared by Controlling Officers on the advice of the heads of departments and submitted to the Finance Department on prescribed dates. The Finance Department consolidates the estimates and prepares the Detailed Estimates called 'Demand for Grants'. The State budget majorly comprises the following documents:
Efficient management of tax administration/other receipts and public expenditure holds the balance for optimum utilization of resources, strengthen scheme implementation and monitoring capacity and achievement of fiscal targets. Persistent savings/excesses indicate need for improvement in the underlying budgetary processes.
Details of total appropriation obtained from state legislature, actual expenditure and savings are summarized in Table 2.1.
Trends in the original budget, revised estimate, and actual expenditure for the period 2020-21 to 2024-25 are given in Table 2.2.
Table 2.2 shows that supplementary provision of ₹41,667 crore during 2024-25 constituted 11.41 per cent of the original provision as against 18.46 per cent in the previous year.
As can be seen in Chart 2.1, the Original Budget and Revised Estimates (RE) for 2024-25 are nearly identical, with actual expenditure only marginally lower than the RE well within acceptable variance. On the other hand, 2023-24 displays a clear divergence, where REs were not matched by corresponding spending, highlighting inefficiencies in fund allocation or implementation.
Component wise analysis of the Budget and Expenditure for the FY 2024-25 is summarized in Table 2.3.
As can be seen from above table, overall budget utilization is about 90 per cent indicating a healthy expenditure pattern. However, it may be noted that total expenditure under CSS was more than 14 per cent less than the budget and State share compensated for the lower Central share indicating the imbalance in CSS funding.
Apart from showing the expenditure against the approved budget, Appropriation Accounts also provide explanation for cases where the expenditure varies significantly from the budgeted provision (Original plus Supplementary). The limit beyond which such variation at the Sub-Head level (unit of Appropriation) to be explained in the Appropriation Accounts is set (September 2004) by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC).
AG (A&E) provides the draft Appropriation Accounts to the Controlling Officers of the Departments and seeks the reasons/explanations for the variations in expenditure with reference to approved budgetary allocation, in keeping with the limits set by the PAC, as given below:
The summary of explanations received in case of variations in Appropriation Accounts is depicted in Chart 2.2.
Out of 5,560 total sub-heads, explanations were required for 1,224 sub heads, while the same have been received for only 498 sub-heads. This indicates that the significant variations in 59 per cent of the sub heads are yet to be addressed.
Expenditure Composition Outturn measures the extent to which re-allocations between the main budget categories during execution have contributed to variance in expenditure composition.
Ayear-wise analysis of grants, excesses, and savings providing valuable insights into the efficiency of budget execution and financial management by the State has been depicted in Chart 2.3.
The expenditure composition outturn for the FY 2024-25 is summarised in Table 2.4.
The Revenue (Voted and Charged) segments show overall controlled expenditure. However, a large number of grants under Revenue (Charged) exhibit significant deviations, indicating the need for more accurate estimation in this category.
The Capital (Voted) segment reflects notable underspending and a wide range of deviations, suggesting underlying issues in planning and implementation. In contrast, while the Capital (Charged) segment appears stable for most grants, the overall deviation is significantly influenced by a few grants with exceptionally high overspending, pointing to critical but isolated lapses.
It is recommended that the GoMP may enhance budget forecasting, especially for capital expenditures, to ensure better alignment between budget estimates and actual utilisation. The Government may consider strengthening the monitoring and control mechanisms for charged expenditures, in view of their relatively higher volatility.
Appropriation Accounts are accounts of the expenditure of the Government for each financial year, compared with the amounts of grants voted and appropriations charged for different purposes as specified in the schedules appended to the Appropriation Act passed under Article 204 of the Constitution of India. These Accounts depict the original budget provision, supplementary grants, surrenders and re-appropriations distinctly in gross basis.
Audit of appropriations by the CAG seeks to ascertain whether the expenditure actually incurred under various grants is in accordance with the authorisation given under the Appropriation Act and that the expenditure required to be charged under the provisions of the Constitution (Article 202) is so charged. It also ascertains whether the expenditure incurred is in conformity with the laws, relevant rules, regulations and instructions.
No money shall be withdrawn from the Consolidated Fund of the State except under appropriation made by law passed in accordance with the provisions of Article 204 of the Constitution. Paragraph 14.3 of the Madhya Pradesh Budget Manual provides that no expenditure can be incurred on a 'new service' or 'new instrument of service' from the Consolidated Fund of the State without prior approval of legislature through supplementary demands for grants. However, in accordance with Article 267(1), in case it is not possible to wait for prior approval of legislature, the State Contingency Fund can be drawn upon for meeting expenditure on the new service/ new instrument of service, pending its authorisation by the Vidhan Sabha.
All expenditure in Madhya Pradesh is being routed through IFMIS. Budget provision is also being made from IFMIS.
It was observed that an expenditure of ₹5,389.42 crore (Appendix 2.1), was incurred in nine cases (more than ₹ two crore in each case) under various components of two grants during the year 2024-25 without having any provision in the original budget estimates/ supplementary demands and without issuing any re-appropriation orders to this effect.
Expenditure under these heads occurred without having provision in original budget, even after the implementation of IFMIS in the state for authorization of the expenditure shows the lack of internal control mechanism and improper monitoring.
Government may consider strengthening internal control mechanism and ensure that the expenditure without budget provision may not occur in future.
As per Article 205 of the Constitution of India, it is mandatory for a State Government to get excesses over grants/appropriations regularised by the State Legislature. Although no time limit for regularisation of expenditure has been prescribed under the Article, the regularisation of excess expenditure is done after the completion of discussion of the Appropriation Accounts by the Public Accounts Committee.
During 2024-25, in Grant No. 6 Finance, the budget provision was `26,326.43 crore and the expenditure was incurred `26,526.19 crore resulting in excess expenditure of `199.75 crore under Revenue Voted section. Schemes under this grant where excess expenditure were incurred are given in Table 2.5 below:
We may see from above table that excess expenditure of ₹2,243.35 crore was occurred in eight schemes which was counter-balanced by savings under other schemes in the grant leading to overall excess expenditure of ₹199.75 crore.
Reasons for excess expenditure in serial no. 3,5 and 6 were mainly attributed to the additional recovery towards pension liabilities, made by the Government of Chhattisgarh from the State of Madhya Pradesh arrived at while revising pension recovery amount for the Financial year 2024-25. No reason was reported in other cases.
Excess disbursements of ₹1,238.29 crore pertaining to 2018-19 to 2024-25 pending for regularisation as shown in Table 2.6 are yet to be regularised from the State Legislature.
The excess expenditure indicates that the budgetary control in the department was ineffective, and budget estimates were not prepared on realistic basis.
Regularisation of existing cases of excess expenditure may be expedited and measures to prevent the recurrence of instances of excess expenditure may be taken by the State Government. All the existing cases of excess expenditure need to be regularised at the earliest.
As per Article 205 of the Constitution, a Supplementary or Additional Grant or Appropriation over the provision made by the Appropriation Act for the year can be made during the current financial year but not after the expiry of the current financial year. When such additional expenditure is found to be inevitable and there is no possibility of effecting savings within the grant to cover the excess by re-appropriation, the Secretary in the Department concerned proposes to the Finance Department for Supplementary or Additional Grant or Appropriation.
The Madhya Pradesh Budget Manual, 2012 permits obtaining of a Supplementary Grant/ Appropriation if the budgetary provision falls short and a commitment for expenditure has already been made under the orders of the competent authority.
The State Legislature approved two supplementary budgets on 17.12.2024 and 11.03.2025 respectively for a total of ₹41,666.97 crore (in respect of 39 Grants and two appropriations) for the year 2024-25. Audit analyses that supplementary provisions of ₹6,253.66 crore during the year 2024-25 in 33 cases (more than ₹ three crore in each case) proved unnecessary (Appendix 2.2) as the expenditure did not come up even to the level of original provision. Similarly, supplementary provisions of ₹5,921.96 crore in 13 cases (more than ₹ three crore in each case) proved excessive (Appendix 2.3) as full amount of supplementary provisions could not be utilised.
Re-appropriation is transfer of funds within a grant from one unit of appropriation, where savings are anticipated, to another unit where additional funds are needed. During 2024-25, re-appropriation orders under 57 grants and two appropriations amounting to ₹ 61,272.36 crore were issued.
Further, in 28 cases (Appendix 2.4-Sl. No. 1 to 28), reduction of provision exceeding ₹ three crore through re-appropriation orders effected by various departments proved injudicious as there was excess expenditure of ₹112.13 crore under these cases where excess expenditure is more than or equal to ₹ one lakh. In seven cases, (Appendix 2.4-Sl. No. 29 to 35) augmentation of provision also proved unnecessary because expenditure was either equal to or did not come up to the level of original/supplementary budget provision which resulted in savings of ₹355.76 crore under these cases where savings is more than or equal to ₹ one lakh.
Budget proposals should strive to strike to optimize all foreseeable expenditure to appropriate spending levels to balance the quality of expenditure and reduce underutilization of budgeted funds. Timely surrenders by the spending units are an important mechanism for optimal reallocation within the approved budget.
The analysis of grants and appropriations showed that in 31 cases (under 21 grants and two appropriations) during the year 2024-25, the savings (excluding surrenders) exceeded ₹100 crore in each case (Appendix 2.5). It was further noticed that in three grants no expenditure was occurred vis-à-vis total grant amounting to ₹42.00 crore as given in Table 2.7 (total budget exceeded ₹ one crore) was incurred during the year 2024-25.
Further, it was also observed that in 42 cases under 31 grants and two appropriations, there were persistent savings exceeding ₹100 crore in each case (Appendix 2.6) during 2022-23 to 2024-25.
Detail of grants grouped by the percentage of utilisation along with total savings during 2024-25 has been shown in Appendix 2.7 and Chart 2.4.
It was noticed that savings under 51 Grants and two appropriations amounting to ₹29,858.45 crore (Appendix 2.8) were not surrendered. Details of savings surrendered on the last day of March (exceeding ₹100 crore in each case) is given in Appendix 2.9.
Analysis of Chart 2.5 revealed that only 41.28 per cent of the savings were surrendered. Out of surrendered amount of ₹20,990.29 crore, ₹20,620.16 crore (98.24 per cent) was surrendered on 31 March 2025.
The Indian Government Accounting Standard-2 was notified by the GoI in 2011 for accounting and classification of Grants-in-Aid received or given by both Central as well as State Governments. As per Indian Government Accounting Standard-2, Grants-in-aid are payments in the nature of assistance, donations or contributions made by one Government to another Government, body, institutions or individual. Further, expenditure on Grants-in-Aid is recorded as Revenue Expenditure in the books of the grantor and as Revenue Receipts in the books of the recipient. As per rule 30 of the Government Accounting Rules,1990 expenditure that only results in the creation of concrete, material and permanent assets should be classified in capital expenditure.
Details of the extent of classification of GIA as Capital Expenditure instead of Revenue Expenditure by the State Government during 2020-21 to 2024-25 as well as the impact of non-compliance with the provisions of IGAS-2 by the State Government in absolute terms during the same period are given in Table 2.8, whereas Chart 2.6 highlights the share of Grants-in-Aid in Capital Expenditure.
Table 2.8 and Chart 2.7 indicate that the non-compliance with the provisions of IGAS-2 by the State in absolute terms during 2020-25 led to overstatement of revenue surplus and understatement of revenue deficit. Moreover, Capital Expenditure during the period was also overstated to that extent.
However, during 2024-25, an amount of ₹2,004.48 crore was misclassified by the State Government as Capital Expenditure instead of accounting for it under Revenue Expenditure. Out of this, ₹347 crore pertains to Grants-in-Aid and ₹1,657.48 crore pertains to other expenditure. Due to this, Revenue Expenditure was understated by ₹2,004.48 crore, and Capital expenditure was overstated by ₹2,004.48 crore. Details are given in Appendix 2.10(a).
Similarly, an amount of ₹12.70 crore was incorrectly budgeted and expended (for 'Machinery' 'Survey, Investigation and Design and Preparation of DPRs' and Investment) as Revenue Expenditure instead of Capital Expenditure by the State Government, due to which Revenue Expenditure was overstated by ₹12.70 crore and Capital Expenditure was understated by ₹12.70 crore. Details are given in Appendix 2.10(b).
Several policy initiatives taken up by the Government are wholly or partially not executed due to non-approval of scheme guidelines/modalities, non-commencement of works for want of administrative sanction, non-release of budget, etc. It was observed that under 24 schemes, there was budget provision of ₹739.33 crore but no expenditure was incurred resulting in non-implementation of schemes as shown in Appendix 2.11.
Further, in 15 out of above 24 schemes, there was approved outlay of ₹179.12 crore which was fully withdrawn in revised outlay as shown in Appendix 2.12.
The observation highlights lapse in budget utilization and scheme implementation in respect of initiatives of the State Government. Corrective action in this regard may be considered to effectively implement the policy initiatives of the Government.
As per Para 26.13 of the Madhya Pradesh Budget Manual, a rush of expenditure particularly in the closing months of the financial year, is regarded as breach of financial regularity.
Table 2.9 shows that a disproportionate share of annual expenditure (36.86 per cent) was executed in the last quarter, with 20.82 per cent in March alone, and a staggering ₹7,290.28 crore spent on just 31 March. This indicates a classic year-end spending spike, which points towards systemic budgeting inefficiencies and calls for stronger financial planning, review mechanisms, and expenditure control.
Trend of total Monthly receipts (Revenue Receipts, Capital Receipts and cash balance) and expenditure during financial year 2024-25 is shown in Chart 2.8 and Chart 2.9.
The quarter wise percentages of expenditure of the state were as follows:
The quarterly details of expenditures incurred across all Grants are shown in Appendix 2.13. The monthly expenditure trend depicted in the chart above and in the Appendix indicate a pronounced skewness towards the last quarter of the financial year and, particularly in the month of March.
Maintaining a steady pace of expenditure is a crucial component of sound public financial management as it prevents fiscal imbalances and temporary cash crunches.
Ministry of Finance, Government of India vide letter No. 1(13) PFMS/FCD/2020 dated 23.03.2021 had notified procedure for release of funds under Centrally Sponsored Scheme (CSS) and monitoring utilization of the funds released through Single Nodal Agency (SNA). For each CSS, SNA is set up with own Bank Account in scheduled Commercial Bank authorised to conduct Government business by the State Government.
As per MoF, GoI's letter dated 16 February, 2023, the State Government shall transfer the Central share as well as the commensurate State share to the SNA account within 30 days of receipt of Central share. In case of delay beyond 30 days in transfer of Central share to the SNA account, interest on the number of days at the rate of 7 per cent per annum has to be paid by the State Government with effect from 01.04.2023.
Audit analysed the VLC data and SNA/PFMS report and found that there was discrepancy in data of Central and State share transfer to SNA accounts, as shown in Table 2.10.
Table 2.10 indicates that discrepancies exist between VLC and PFMS figures. These figures are required to be reconciled regularly between PFMS and VLC to maintain accurate financial records.
To enhance oversight of the availability and utilization of funds released under Centrally Sponsored Schemes (CSS), the Department of Expenditure introduced revised guidelines for fund flow procedures. These guidelines aim to implement the principles of 'just-in-time releases' for payments, ensuring more efficient cash management at both the Central and State levels. As part of this effort, an alternative fund flow mechanism, SNA-SPARSH a real-time system for the integrated and swift transfer of CSS funds was introduced. This system operates through a seamless framework integrating the Public Financial Management System (PFMS), State Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS), and e-Kuber of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), facilitating efficient and transparent fund disbursement.
As per the revised procedure notified by the Ministry of Finance, State Governments are required to transfer both the Central and State share of funds to the Single Nodal Agency (SNA) Account under the SNA-SPARSH model and all releases are to be routed exclusively through the Public Financial Management System (PFMS). Further, all SNAs and Implementing Agencies must be registered in the State Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS), and funds are to be released on a just-in-time basis directly to beneficiaries or vendors, without routing through Personal Deposit (PD) accounts or other intermediary accounts, thereby promoting improved cash management and transparency.
SNA SPARSH model has been implemented in Madhya Pradesh State. As regards opening of account in regional office of RBI, Bhopal, state government submits proposal to this office for consent of the same. As on 20.08.2025, this office has given consent to open 141 SNA accounts (SLS wise) on SNA-SPARSH model. As information by State Government, almost 190 schemes are required to be onboarded on SNA-SPARSH model.
This shows good progress but indicates there is still a way to go for full integration. Continuous coordination between the state government and RBI is essential to complete the onboarding of all schemes. Full onboarding of all schemes will enhance financial transparency, ease of fund flow monitoring, and scheme wise accounting. Timely consent for remaining accounts is critical to avoid delays in scheme fund management.
The Contingency Fund of Government of Madhya Pradesh was established under the Section 3 of Madhya Pradesh Contingency Fund Act, 1957, and the State Government made the Madhya Pradesh Contingency Fund Rules, 1957 for regulating all matters connected with or ancillary to the custody of payment of monies into and the withdrawal of monies from the Contingency Fund of the State of Madhya Pradesh for meeting unforeseen expenditure. The fund is recouped when the State Legislature authorises the additional expenditure. The corpus of the Fund is ₹1,000.00 crore.
Advances from the Contingency Fund are to be made only for meeting expenditure of an unforeseen and emergent character, postponement of which, till its authorisation by the Legislature, would be undesirable.
During FY 2024-25, an amount of ₹12.60 crore was withdrawn as an advance by three Departments namely Social Justice & Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities, Higher Education, and Technical Education and Skill Development and Employment, from the Contingency Fund in respect of three schemes. All the amounts were recouped till the end of the FY 2024-25 along with the previous year amount of ₹15.00 crore under Major Head 2052-'Secretariat- General Services'. Major Head wise details of the expenditure incurred, are given in Table 2.11.
Details of schemes in which amounts were withdrawn as advances from the Contingency Fund, are given in Table 2.12.
It is clear from the Table 2.12, that in serial no.1, it was unnecessary to withdraw the advance of ₹2.16 crore in the scheme 34-2235-02-104-1456-42-007 Atal Vayo Abhyudaya as the expenditure was not even up to the level of original budget.
After voting on Demands for Grants in the Legislative Assembly, an Appropriation Bill is introduced for appropriation out of the Consolidated Fund of the State for moneys required to meet (a) the grants made by the Assembly and (b) the expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund. After the Governor's assent to the Bill, amounts shown in the Appropriation Act and schedules thereof become the sanctioned grants for expenditure under various Demands.
During the year 2024-25, two Grants were selected for audit, i.e., Grant No. 12-Energy and Grant No. 52-Medical Education for detailed scrutiny to review compliance with prescribed budgetary procedures, monitoring of funds, control mechanisms and implementation of schemes within these grants.
We reviewed (September 2025) the budgetary procedure and control over expenditure pertaining to the Grant No. 12 "Energy". Secretary, Department of Energy, Bhopal (code no 1301) and Chief Electrical Inspector & Advisor, Bhopal (code no 1302) are the Budget Controlling Officers (BCOs) of Grant No. 12.
The details of amount budgeted for, and the expenditure incurred under the Grant No. 12 during 2024-25 is summarised below in Table 2.13.
As can be seen from the above Table 2.13 that, under section Revenue (voted), original budget as approved by the legislature was ₹23,707.99 crore and actual budget released to Budget Controlling Officers (BCOs) by Finance Department (FD) was ₹19,677.82 crore. Thus, there was a short release of ₹4,030.17 crore. Similarly, budget under section Capital (voted) was ₹8,557.47 crore, and the budget release to BCOs was ₹8,400.47 crore, thus there was a short release of ₹157 crore.
As per Appropriation Accounts 2024-25, against the provision of ₹23,707.99 crore (Revenue), expenditure of ₹19,662.44 crore was incurred resulting in unspent provision of ₹4,045.55 crore (17.06 per cent). Further, against the provision of ₹8,557.47 crore (Capital), expenditure of ₹6,769.56 crore was incurred resulting in unspent provision of ₹1,787.91 crore (20.89 per cent). Huge savings indicates that the BCOs had not given due care and also not complied budget manual at the time of preparation of budget estimates.
The matter is brought to the notice of the Government; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
According to Paras 30.1 and 30.2 of Budget Manual, departments should carry out budget monitoring by reviewing expenditure incurred by departments during a financial year. The primary objective of such monitoring is to ensure that State budget presented and approved by the Vidhan Sabha remains a reliable guide to the actual expenditure incurred during the financial year. The monitoring should include not only expenditure incurred in the current financial year but should also made a comparison and analysis of past expenditure data for the last three years.
Audit observed that during the last five years from 2020-21 to 2024-25, there were persistent savings of more than ₹0.33 crore in six schemes ranging between 3.24 per cent to 100 per cent of the total budget allotment under the relevant appropriation as shown below in Table 2.14:
It can be seen from the above table that savings during 2024-25 were mainly in the Schemes viz., 15th Finance Commission (7837), Green Corridor (0700), Strengthening of Transmission system (1284) and RDSS (9542). The persistent savings is indicative of poor budgetary monitoring or shortfall in performance or both. This also showed that budget allocations were made without considering the previous years' trends in expenditure which resulted in persistent savings.
The matter is brought to the notice of the Government; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
The main objective of the schemes under Grant 12 is to strengthen the electrical infrastructure and maintain reliable & affordable power supply, operational efficiencies and financial sustainability of Power sector.
Audit observed that during 2024-25, there were substantial savings of ₹5,607.08 crore in nine schemes, where savings were ₹4.99 crore or above which was ranging between 13.58 to 64.40 per cent of the total budget allotment. The details are shown below in Table 2.15.
As shown in Table 2.15 the major savings were under SSTD (7900), Strengthening of Transmission system (6929) and RDSS (9542) schemes which shows that department could not meet the targeted creation/strengthening of transmission/distribution infrastructure in the State.
The matter is brought to the notice of the Government; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
During 2024-25, in 20 cases, where provision was ₹ one crore or more, the entire provision of the schemes aggregating to ₹19,267.03 crore, out of which budget allotment of ₹8,749.94 crore (45.47 per cent) released by the Finance Department was not utilised by the Energy department as detailed below in Table 2.16.
As shown in Table 2.16 entire provision of 20 Scheme heads remained unutilised. Further it was observed that the provision made under Scheme-7837 (Assistance for making required improvements as per 15th Finance Commission) was re-appropriated to the other schemes which indicates that the said provision was not required at all.
The matter is brought to the notice of the Government; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
According to Paras 28.8 and 28.9 of Budget manual Vol-1, the primary responsibility of preparing and justifying for supplementary grants rests on BCOs. Proposals for supplementary grants or appropriation should be submitted by the controlling officer to the concerned administrative department and administrative department should examine the proposals very carefully and recommend to the Finance Department only those that are considered to be fully justified.
We observed that during the year 2024-25 in three schemes, supplementary/re-appropriation amounting to ₹1,797.58 crore proved unnecessary as the savings were equal or more than the supplementary provision/Re-appropriation in these schemes, as detailed below in Table 2.17.
This indicates that proposals for supplementary budget were sent to Finance Department without assessing the actual requirement. As unnecessary provisioning reflects injudicious budgetary exercise, robust checks should be placed to avoid such occurrences. Further, re-appropriation of funds which is an exercise of the budget controlling authorities with reference to the budget/expenditure, needs to be carried out in rigorous manner.
The matter is brought to the notice of the Government; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
Scrutiny of records made available by the Budget Controlling Officer (BCO), Chief Engineer (Electrical Safety), and Chief Electrical Inspector (BCO code 1302) revealed that the balance budget held by DDOs was not surrendered to the BCO within the stipulated time (before 15th January). The details are shown below in the Table 2.18.
It can be seen from the above table that out of ₹38.14 crore of allotted budget, BCO could allot only ₹27.87 crore to the DDOs.
Further, the balance budget with the DDOs (₹0.22 crore) was not surrendered to the BCO within the stipulated time (before 15th January).
The matter is brought to the notice of higher authorities; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
According to Paras 30.1 and 30.2 of Budget Manual, department should carry out budget monitoring by reviewing expenditure incurred by departments during a financial year. The primary objective of such monitoring is to ensure that State budget presented and approved by the Vidhan Sabha remains a reliable guide to the actual expenditure incurred during the financial year.
We observed that during the year 2024-25, an amount of ₹30.00 crore was included in the Budget Estimate approved by the legislature under the scheme 1436 - Chief Minister Krishak Mitra Scheme, in Grant No. 12, however, no corresponding estimates/allotments were reflected in BCO statements.
We further observed that during the year 2024-25, an amount of ₹75.49 crore, was shown in the BCO statements, under the scheme (1216- Loans from Rural Electrification Corporation of ₹53.49 crore and 1217- Interest on loans from Rural Electrification Corporation Limited of ₹22.00 crore), however, no corresponding estimates/allotments were reflected in the Budget under Grant No.12 of Energy Department.
This shows ineffective budget monitoring and lack of coordination between Budget formulation and BCO.
The matter is brought to the notice of the Government; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
According to para 26.9 of the Madhya Pradesh Budget Manual Vol I, statements of anticipated savings in expenditure are required to be submitted by the Budget Controlling Officers to the Finance Department by 15th January for each financial year so that resources can be allocated by Finance Department to other demand of grants.
We observed that during the year 2024-25 in two schemes savings aggregating to ₹15.51 crore (8.05 per cent) of total provision of ₹192.67 crore should have been surrendered to Government within stipulated timeline i.e. 15th January. However, the same was not surrendered to Government within the 2024-25. Details are shown in Table 2.19 below.
Further it was observed that BCO prepared a statement of surrender in April 2025.
This indicates inadequate financial control by the BCO resulted in non-utilization of the funds for other development programmes/purpose during the respective year.
The matter is brought to the notice of the Government; Reply is still awaited (January 2026).
Audit reviewed (September 2025) the budgetary procedures and expenditure control pertaining to Grant No. 52 - Medical Education at the Directorate of Medical Education, Bhopal, which serves as the Budget Controlling Officer (BCO) for this grant.
During the budgetary review of Grant No. 52 for the year 2024-25, the following deficiencies were observed, as detailed below:
As per para-B.5 of Budget Manual-I, BCOs serve as the crucial link between the Administrative Department, Finance Department, Accountant General and disbursing officers in all stages of the budget cycle from preparation of estimates to reconciliation of accounts with the Accountant General.
There were variations between Appropriation Accounts and records provided by the BCO as given in Table 2.20 below:
It is evident from the above table that:
i. The budget as approved by the legislature was ₹4,930.82 crore and actual budget released to Budget Controlling Officers (BCOs) by Finance Department (FD) was ₹4,758.70 crore. Thus, there was a short release of ₹172.12 crore to the BCOs from the actual budget approved by the legislature.
ii As per Appropriation Accounts 2024-25, against the provision of ₹4,930.82 crore, expenditure of ₹3,838.89 crore was incurred resulting in unspent provision of ₹1,091.93 crore (22 per cent). Thus, the significant amount of budget could not be utilized.
During audit it was noticed that there was difference of ₹21.64 crore (₹4,930.82 crore- ₹4,909.18 crore) between original budget figures of AG and BCO and difference of ₹0.91 crore (₹3,838.89 crore - ₹3,837.98 crore) in the expenditure figures of AG and BCO.
In reply, Department stated that the department's allocation was initially reduced by 10-20 per cent, and remaining funds were to be released only after expenditure reached the allocated limit. Since the actual expenditure was lower than the budget allocation, the Finance Department did not release the remaining funds, making the allocation appear less than provisioned. Further, reconciliation between the department's figures and AG's figures will be carried out in future to resolve these differences.
The reply is silent about the reasons for reduction in allocation and expenditure not meeting the budget allocation. Further, had the BCO office reconciled the expenditure figures with the Accountant General's office in a timely manner, these discrepancies would have been avoided.
According to Paras 30.1 and 30.2 of Budget Manual, department should carry out budget monitoring by reviewing expenditure incurred by departments during a financial year. The primary objective of such monitoring is to ensure that State budget presented and approved by the Vidhan Sabha remains a reliable guide to the actual expenditure incurred during the financial year. The monitoring should include not only expenditure incurred in the current financial year but should also include a comparison and analysis of past expenditure data for the last three years.
We observed that during the last three years from 2022-23 to 2024-25, there were persistent savings of more than ₹ one crore in nine schemes ranging between two per cent and 100 per cent of the total budget allotment under the relevant appropriation as shown in Table 2.21 below:
It is evident from the above table that savings were mainly in the activities of Salaries and Allowances, Material and Supply and Machine during 2024-25. The persistent savings are indicative of poor budgetary monitoring or shortfall in performance or both. This also showed that budget allocations were made without considering the previous years' trends in expenditure, which resulted in persistent savings.
The department replied that budget provisions were made based on the expectation of filling new posts; however, as the posts remained vacant, the allocated budget could not be utilized. It was further stated that in the future, budget provisions will be prepared considering scheme heads where savings are likely to occur.
Thus, reply indicates that budget allocations for schemes are being made in anticipation of filling of new post. Further, it does not explain the reasons for savings under the heads of maintenance and machinery.
The main objective of the Schemes was to provide best tertiary health care facilities for the people of the State by establishing new medical colleges and strengthening existing medical colleges including super specialty hospitals, cancer and mental hospitals. Substantial savings in the budget heads against the appropriation approved by the State Legislature defeated the goal of the Government to provide best tertiary health care facilities to the people of the State.
We observed that there were substantial savings of ₹1,074.51 crore in 15 schemes, where savings were ₹20 crore or more ranging between nine per cent and 100 per cent of the total budget allotment during 2024-25 as detailed in Table 2.22 below:
The Department replied that the savings occurred due to delays in approval processes for construction works, lower demand for scholarships and professional services, and a slow process of procurement of machinery and equipment.
Thus, the reply indicates that the department lacked in optimizing the efforts to ensure full utilization of the budget provisions under various schemes.
As per paras B-7 and 8 of Madhya Pradesh Budget Manual (MPBM) Vol-I (Part-B), all BCOs are responsible for collating estimates of expenditure and receipts from the DDOs under them as well as estimates of Off Budget funds likely to be received for departmental schemes during the ensuing financial year for finalisation of estimates of expenditure and receipts. BCOs should collate all estimates prepared by DDOs and review the same periodically.
Audit noticed that while preparing the budget estimates by the BCO, information was not collated from the DDOs before finalisation of the budget estimates. Further, it was observed that the department had spent ₹3,835.79 crore against the allotted amount of ₹4,758.69 crore during the financial year 2024-25, which indicates that budget estimates were made without assessing the actual requirement at DDOs level, resulting in blockage of funds as well as violation of said provisions.
Department replied that the savings were due to non-release of the Central share, lower expenditure on medicines, consumables, machinery, equipment and construction works, and vacancies in various medical colleges.
This reply indicates that the Department did not properly consider the availability of the Central share, actual spending requirements, and existing vacancies while preparing the Budget Estimates, resulting in large savings.
During 2024-25, in 33 cases, where provision was ₹ one crore or more, the entire provision of the schemes after re-appropriation remained unutilized at the end of year as detailed inTable 2.23 below:
Thus, against the total budget provision of ₹602.99 crore approved by State Legislature, the BCO made re-appropriation of ₹155.72 crore by decreasing the budget, however, the entire available budget of ₹447.27 crore of 33 schemes was not utilized.
The department replied that although budget provisions and allocations were made, the Central share of funds was not released, which in turn prevented the drawl of the corresponding State share. Consequently, no expenditure was incurred against these allocations.
Thus, the fact remains that the budget allotted for medical facilities under the scheme could not be operationalized as planned, and the intended works, remained incomplete.
As per para B.13 of Budget Manual during the course of the financial year, BCOs are also responsible for obtaining necessary sanctions for re-appropriations and supplementary grants.
During the budgetary process, it was noticed that, in the case of four scheme heads, augmentation of funds through re-appropriation proved unnecessary, as the actual expenditure was less than the original budget, as detailed in Table 2.24 below:
It is evident from above table that augmentation of ₹40.58 crore in original budget was proved unnecessary as the actual expenditure of ₹803.95 crore was less than the original budget of ₹992.74 crore.
Department replied that re-appropriation was made under the concerned budget heads in anticipation of higher expenditure; however, due to lower demand for expenditure, the actual expenditure was less than the original budget.
Thus, it is evident from the reply that while re-appropriating funds under the scheme heads, the estimation was not assessed appropriately.
Para B.29 of the Budget Manual specified that if the Administrative Department anticipates savings then it should be surrendered to the Finance Department. Such an exercise should be undertaken by 15th of January for each financial year so that resources can be allocated by Finance Department to other demand of grants. Further, para no. 6.1 of Finance Department's orders (July 2021) also reiterated the same instructions. The status of unspent budget/saving during 2024-25 is given in Table 2.25 below:
As per Appropriation Accounts of 2024-25, saving of ₹1,091.93 crore had occurred against the total budget provision of ₹4,930.82 crore. However, during the scrutiny of records related to surrender of saving it was noticed that no amount of saving was surrendered during the financial year by the Department and a bulk amount of saving of ₹879.98 crore under various budget heads was surrendered on 31 March 2025 which leaves no scope for Finance Department to utilising the funds for other development programmes.
Department replied that all possible efforts were made to utilize the budget provisions before 31 March. However, due to periodic restrictions imposed by the Finance Department, budget provisions were reduced. Subsequently, when funds were reallocated, delays in approvals by the Finance Department for drawal created uncertainty, resulting in incomplete utilization of budget provisions. Furthermore, savings could not be surrendered in time due to delays in the supply of materials by construction agencies and suppliers of medicines, consumables, and machinery, as well as the late submission of bills by subordinate institutions.
The reply indicates that the department lacked in planning and executing the activities in accordance with the budget provision under the further more schemes. Surrender of budget on the last day of Financial Year prevented the Finance Department from effectively reallocating the funds to other departments or priority areas.
As per Rule 14 of the Madhya Pradesh Financial Code, Volume I, all charges incurred shall be paid within the same financial year and shall not be carried forward for payment from the appropriation of a subsequent year. If necessary, the expenditure may be postponed until provisions are made in the new budget and the required sanction is obtained. However, under no circumstances should an expenditure incurred in one year be charged to the appropriation of another year.
Audit noticed that subordinate Drawing and Disbursing Officers (DDOs) demanded additional budget in various heads to enable them to make the payment of pending liabilities of previous years (2021-22 to 2023-24). Consequently, the BCO allowed them to make the payment of pending liabilities of previous year from the budget allotment of current year (2024-25). The total amount of allotment was ₹1.91 crore.
The allotment of additional budget in various heads for payment of pending liabilities of previous years was contrary to the provisions of Madhya Pradesh Financial Code.
Department replied that subordinate institutions were permitted to clear pending liabilities from previous years using the budget allocation of the financial year 2024-25, based on their requests for funds to settle outstanding bills. It was further assured that, in future, all subordinate institutions would be instructed not to make such payments from the current year's budget.
The reply itself indicates that the department was charging the previous years liabilities in current financial year in contravention to the provisions of Budget Manual.
As per provisions contained in Budget Manual, Vol.-I, Chapter-26, Para-26.13, the Drawing and Disbursing Officers (DDOs) are required to regulate the pace of expenditure in such a manner that it is evenly distributed throughout the financial year. The Manual specifically discourages a rush of expenditure towards the close of the financial year, as it indicates poor financial planning and may result in infructuous or irregular spending.
Audit observed that the pattern of expenditure was irregular, with a disproportionately high amount incurred during the last quarter, particularly in the final month of the financial year. This trend is contrary to the principle of proportionate expenditure distribution prescribed in the Budget Manual. The details of such expenditure are provided in Table 2.26 below:
It is evident from the above, expenditure incurred at the close of the financial year was 32.21 per cent in the last quarter and 20.06 per cent in March 2025 alone, which is indicative of rush of expenditure in contravention to the provisions of Budget Manual ibid.
Department replied that restrictions imposed by the Finance Department on monthly withdrawals limited the fund utilization during earlier quarters, leading to the release of unutilized amounts in the last quarter or month, which resulted in higher expenditure during that period.
The fact remains that the expenditure pattern was not maintained in a balanced or consistent manner throughout the year, contrary to the guidelines prescribed in the Budget Manual.
Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure), GoI issued (June 2021) instructions regarding release of funds to States for Centrally Sponsored Schemes (CSS) and monitoring utilization of the funds. In this regard, it was directed that a Single Nodal Agency (SNA) is designated for each CSS by every State Government. Each SNA is registered in the Public Financial Management System (PFMS) and the bank account of each SNA is opened and mapped in PFMS.
In the department under the Grant No.52, 10 Centrally Sponsored Schemes were operated during 2024-25 as detailed in Table 2.27 below:
On verification of CSS following shortcomings were noticed:
During the scrutiny of records related to budget provisions and allotments, details regarding the submission of Utilization Certificates (UCs) to the Government of India for funds received under Centrally Sponsored Schemes (CSS) were sought. The records provided by the department revealed that no UCs were submitted for the years 2023-24 and 2024-25. Consequently, the extent of utilization of funds released under CSS could not be verified during the audit.
Ministry of Finance (DoE), GoI issued (January 2024) directions that on boarding of a scheme into SNA-SPARSH platform, the State Government shall close all the SNA accounts pertaining to the scheme and return the Central Share of unspent balance lying in the SNA accounts to the Consolidated Fund of India (CFI). Similarly, the State share of unspent balance in the SNA accounts should be returned to the Consolidated Fund of the State.
Audit observed that out of 10 CSS, only one SNA (Scheme 7853 - Establishment of New Medical Colleges) was fully closed, while bank statements for seven SNAs were submitted. The status of unspent balances remaining in these bank accounts is provided in Table 2.28 below:
Thus, an unspent balance of ₹312.72 crore remained in the bank accounts and was not returned to the Consolidated Fund of India.
During examination of allotment of Central and State Share under the Centrally Sponsored Schemes it was noticed that in four Centrally Sponsored Schemes, the State Share of ₹4.84 crore was released less in comparison to Central Share.
The department stated that the process of closing these Single Nodal Agency (SNA) accounts is currently underway, and the funds in these accounts are being transferred to the Central and State Governments in the prescribed ratio. It was further mentioned that future transfers will be carried out through the Central Treasury under the SNA-SPARSH scheme.
However, the fact remains that all SNA accounts have not yet been closed, and the remaining funds have not been transferred to the Consolidated Funds of the Centre and State in accordance with the applicable ratio.
Para B.12 of MP Budget Manual stipulates that once the budgetary allocations approved by the Legislature are communicated to the BCOs, they are responsible for disbursing the funds to the DDOs under their control.
Audit observed that the BCO did not disburse funds to the DDOs under seven schemes, each having a provision of ₹10.00 lakh or more during 2024-25. Consequently, the budget of ₹34.16 crore remained unutilized, as detailed in Table 2.29 below:
The department replied that the savings occurred due to non-receipt of payment demands related to the procurement of medicines, consumables, and construction works. Reply is not acceptable, as timely release of funds to subordinate units could have facilitated expenditure under these schemes, thereby avoiding such savings.
The operation and maintenance of Personal Deposit (PD) Accounts are governed by Subsidiary Rules 542 and 543 of the Madhya Pradesh Treasury Code, Volume I. As per these provisions, PD account shall be opened only with prior approval of the Government, after consultation with the Accountant General, and only when the Government is satisfied that proper initial accounts will be maintained and subjected to audit.
Furthermore, the rules stipulate that if PD account remains inoperative for a continuous period of three years, the Treasury Officer shall issue a written notice to the Administrator of the account, requiring an explanation within one month as to why the unutilized balance should not be transferred to Government Revenue Deposits.
During the scrutiny of records relating to funds maintained under the head 8443 (Civil Deposits) it was observed that Personal Deposit (PD) Account No. 31 was operated by the Directorate of Medical Education in the treasury for the receipt and payment of admission fees collected from students of autonomous medical colleges for graduate and postgraduate courses. However, the account has remained inoperative since September 15, 2022, with no transactions recorded for the past three years, and the unspent balance of ₹36.78 crore had not been transferred to the Consolidated Fund of the State as required under the rules.
The department replied that the process for closure of the Personal Deposit Account is presently under progress.
Out of total budget provision of ₹4,06,734.33 crore during the year 2024-25, an expenditure of ₹3,55,885.58 crore was incurred against the 57 grants and two appropriations leaving savings of ₹50,848.76 crore.
During the last four years (2021-25), budgetary provisions increased consistently but the percentage of utilization of budget never reached 90 per cent highlighting the consistent overestimation of budgetary provisions and lack of control over the execution and monitoring of budget.
Departments surrendered ₹20,620.16 crore on the last working day of the Financial Year, leaving no scope for utilising these funds for other purposes.
Despite flagging the issue several times with the Finance Department and mentioning in the Reports of the CAG on the finances of the State Government, the latter continued to misclassify revenue expenditures of ₹2,004.48 crore in the capital section, which impacted the revenue surplus and other fiscal parameters.
There were 13 grants where more than 50 per cent of the expenditure of ₹32,252.05 crore incurred in the last quarter of Financial Year pointing out the poor expenditure discipline and increases the risk of unproductive and hasty spending.