SFAR Madhya Pradesh 2024-25
State Finances Audit Report
Government of Madhya Pradesh
This chapter provides broad based perspective of quality of the State Government Accounts rendered by various authorities of the State Government and status of compliance with prescribed financial rule, procedures and directives. Compliance with financial rules, procedures and directives as well as the completeness, timeliness and quality of reporting on the status of such compliance enhances relevance and reliability of the information presented in the financial reports.
Article 293(3) of the Constitution of India mandates consent of Government of India for a State Government's borrowing if it has any outstanding loans or guarantees from the Government of India. Further, the Fifteenth Finance Commission recommended that the normal Net Borrowing Ceiling (NBC) for State Governments be fixed at three per cent of GSDP for the period 2023-24 to 2025-26, with additional borrowing space of 0.50 per cent linked to power sector reforms and 0.62 per cent for capital investment works for the year 2024-25, aggregating to a total borrowing limit of 4.12 per cent of GSDP.
Bypassing the above stipulated net borrowing ceiling by routing loans outside budget through various State Government Public Sector Undertaking (SPSUs)/ Corporations/ other Bodies despite the State being responsible for repayment of such loans pose significant risk to fiscal health and transparency in the Government finances. The Borrowing Ceilings for a financial year of the State Governments are now being reduced by GoI to the extent of Off-Budget Borrowings.
The State Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act, 2005 outlined that the State Government shall take suitable measures to ensure greater transparency in its fiscal operations in public interest by disclosing the actual liabilities arising out of Off Budget Borrowings by PSUs, Special Purpose Vehicles and other equivalent instruments where liability for repayment is on the State Government allocations. Further, the State Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Rules, 2006 provided that the 'Medium Term Fiscal Restructuring Policy (MTFRP) Statement' laid before the Legislature along with Budget documents shall contain the five- year rolling targets with respect to Revenue Deficit, Fiscal Deficit and total outstanding debt 27 of the State Government.
For the year 2024-25, debt was targeted as 32.32 per cent of GSDP under MTFRP and 33.60 per cent under FRBM Act. Besides, on the recommendation of the Fifteenth Finance Commission, GoI had fixed maximum limit of borrowing ceiling at 4.12 per cent of GSDP (₹15,03,395 crore), amounting to ₹61,939.87 crore for the State during 2024-25.
State Government did not provide the complete details of off budget borrowings in its budget. Further, as per information furnished by the State Government to GoI as on 31 March 2025, the outstanding off budget borrowing was ₹3,468.34 crore which included borrowings of ₹568.12 crore borrowed during 2024-25 as detailed in Table 3.1:
Apart from the off-budget borrowings as depicted in Table 3.1, out of 73 SPSUs/Corporations/Autonomous Bodies under the audit jurisdiction of the CAG of India, only three SPSUs provided information regarding off budget borrowings. Audit examination revealed that the State Government routed additionally ₹1,630.84 crore loans outside the budget through various State PSUs/ Authorities, as detailed in Table 3.2. Total outstanding off-budget borrowings as a percentage of GSDP is depicted in Chart 3.1.
As per information furnished by the SPSUs, none of these three electricity distribution companies have received any financial assistance from the Government of Madhya Pradesh for either interest payment obligations or principal repayment of their loans.
Undischarged liabilities, such as non-transfer of collected cess to designated bodies or short remittances to the National Pension System (NPS), etc. can have significant long-term fiscal and governance implications. These unpaid obligations accumulate over time, creating hidden liabilities that distort the true financial position of the State. Further, delays in cess transfer hinder the intended development or welfare outcomes, defeating the purpose for which such levies were imposed. Similarly, short transfers to NPS not only violate statutory commitments but also compromise the financial security of employees. Over the years, such practices can erode trust, trigger legal liabilities and increase future expenditure obligations, thereby constraining fiscal space and weakening fiscal sustainability. Such cases are discussed in succeeding paragraphs.
The Government has a liability to provide and pay interest on the amount in the interest-bearing deposits/Reserve funds.
Audit observed that ₹559.22 crore was required to be paid as interest on the balance of ₹13,195.78 crore lying under interest bearing deposit/Reserve funds as on 1 April 2024 as shown in Table 3.3. However, provision for the same was not made.
Short payment of interest amounting to ₹559.22 crore has resulted in understatement of Revenue Expenditure and over statement of Revenue surplus to that extent.
The National Mineral Exploration Trust (NMET) was established in August 2015 under Section 9C of the MMDR Act, 1957. As per Section 9C (4) of this Act, holder of a mining lease or a mineral concession are required to contribute 2 per cent of the royalty paid to the trust. As per the NMET Rules, the State Government is responsible for collecting these contributions, depositing them in the Public Account under Major Head '8449-123-NMET Deposits', and transferring the funds monthly to the Consolidated Fund of India.
The opening balance under MH-8449-123 as on 1 April 2024 was ₹0.12 crore and an amount of ₹89.24 crore was deposited during 2024-25. However, during the year, only ₹89.24 crore has been transferred to Government of India, ignoring the opening balance of ₹0.12 crore by the State Government.
The Ministry of Mines, Government of India, vide its letter dated 19 November 2024, advised all State Governments to establish a State Mineral Exploration Trust (SMET)/ State Mineral Development Fund (SMDF) on the lines of the National Mineral Exploration Trust (NMET), as mandated under clause (g) of sub-section (A) of Section 15 of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957.
The State Government did not furnish the information in respect of establishing the State Mineral Development Fund as of December 2025.
Promptness in disposal of refund cases is an important indicator of performance of the Department concerned. During the year 2024-25, the information pertaining to pendency of refund cases was called from various departments viz. Department of Commercial Tax, Excise, Transport, Mines and Geology, Stamps and Registration, Forest and Department of revenue. However, only the Department of Stamps and Registration, provided the details of refund cases during the year 2024-25. The details are given in Table 3.4.
As can be seen from the above table, during 2024-25, the number of pending refund claims increased from 4,890 cases to 5,399 cases, reflecting a net increase of 509 cases (10.41 per cent).
In terms of Rule 182 of the Madhya Pradesh Financial Code, the departmental officers shall furnish the Utilization Certificates (UCs) in respect of conditional Grants-in-Aids to the Accountant General on or before 30th September of the following year from which grant-in-aid related. To the extent of non-submission of UCs, there is a risk that the amount shown in Finance Accounts may not have reached the beneficiaries.
During the year 2024-25, 33 Grant-in-aids bills amounting ₹1,758.88 crore become due for UCs. As on 31st March 2025, 19,897 UCs for ₹22,049.38 crore were outstanding. of these, 275 outstanding UCs for ₹4,241.10 crore were cleared. During the year 2024-25, 61,517 Conditional Grants amounting ₹42,310.70 crore were issued which will become due in 2025-26. Out of these, 10 UCs amounting to ₹5.65 crore were received. Age-wise details of delays in submission of UCs are given in Table 3.5:
As can be seen from the above Table, 76 per cent of outstanding utilisation certificates (61,507) pertain to the period 2024-25 and 24 per cent (outstanding UCs 19,227) pertain to the period upto 2014-15. In the absence of accountability for expenditure relating to funds provided as far back as 10 years or more, the possibility of misappropriation of these funds cannot be ruled out. Further, delay in submission of UCs may affect receipt of performance grants from GoI.
The Department-wise break-up of outstanding Utilisation Certificates for grants released up to the year 2024-25 is given in Appendix 3.1. The pendency of UCs is spread across 31 Departments of the State Government and their status in respect of five major pendencies is presented in Chart 3.2.
Since non-submission of UCs is fraught with the risk of mis-utilisation, it is imperative that the State Government should monitor this aspect closely and hold the persons concerned accountable for submission of UCs in a timely manner.
During scrutiny of the records, it was observed that out of the total grant of ₹53.05 crore, Utilisation Certificates amounting to only ₹0.05 crore had been submitted by the Department, while the remaining UCs are still pending.
In response to audit observation, the department stated that UCs would be obtained from the districts and furnished to the Audit.
The reply is not acceptable, as UCs have been pending for period of one to five years. This indicates that the Department failed to ensure timely submission and proper, purpose-oriented utilization of the grants.
The matter was referred to the Government (September 2025); their reply was awaited (December 2025).
Non-submission of UCs constitutes a violation of financial rules and undermines accountability as well as assurance regarding proper and purpose-oriented utilisation of public funds.
The matter was referred to the Government (July 2025); In response, the Department stated (October 2025) that UCs amounting to ₹28.11 lakh had been received from research institutions. The reply was not acceptable, as no UCs were furnished to Audit for verification. A letter was subsequently issued to the Department to obtain the requisite documents, and the matter was again brought to the notice of the Government (November 2025). Further response was awaited (December 2025).
Under the List of Major and Minor Heads of Accounts of Union and States, Personal Deposits are of the nature of deposits not bearing interest opened under 8443-Civil Deposits-106-Personal Deposits.
During the year 2024-25, an amount of ₹12,085.57 crore was transferred/deposited from the Consolidated Fund of the State to Personal Deposit (PD) Accounts under head 8443-106. Details of PD accounts as on 31 March 2025 are given in Table 3.10.
As can be seen from the above table, as of 31 March 2025, 679 Personal Deposit Accounts were in existence and the closing balance in these accounts was ₹4,812.13 crore. Further, the amount of ₹12,085.57 crore transferred during 2024-25 included ₹1,548.00 crore transferred from Consolidated Fund of the State and challans in March 2025. Of which, ₹726.00 crore was transferred on the last working day of March 2025 from the Consolidated Fund of the State.
Further, out of 679 Administrators of PD accounts only 194 Administrators of Personal Deposit Accounts had reconciled and verified their balances with the treasury figures as per the provision contained in Rule 359 and 376 of the Madhya Pradesh Treasury Code. Remaining 485 Administrators of Personal Deposit Accounts had not reconciled and verified their balances with the treasury figures.
Non transfer of unspent balances lying in the PD accounts to the Consolidated Fund of the State entails the risk of misuse of public fund, fraud and misappropriation.
The closing balances in the PD Accounts for the period from 2020-21 to 2024 25 are indicated in Table 3.11.
As can be seen from the above table, the closing balances in these accounts have fluctuated significantly over the five years. In 2020-21, the closing balance stood at ₹4,962.59 crore in respect of 816 PD Accounts, which declined to ₹2,636.40 crore in 2021-22 and further to ₹2,353.57 crore in 2022-23. A sharp reduction was observed in 2023-24, when the balance turned negative at ₹(-)917.24 crore due to non-reflection of Works to PD account transfer transaction in the compiled accounts of Public Works Division, Water Resource Division, etc., reflecting higher expenditure (₹5,369.20 crore) compared to receipts (₹2,098.40 crore). In 2024-25, receipts increase sharply to ₹12,085.57 crore, However, the same could not be utilised and led to closing balance of ₹4,812.13 crore pertaining to 679 PD accounts. However, the number of operational PD accounts also showed a declining trend from 816 in 2020-21 to 679 in 2024-25 (17 per cent), indicating efforts toward consolidation and closure of inactive accounts.
Rule 319(2) of Madhya Pradesh Treasury Code states that, if a PD Account has remained un-operated upon a continuous period of three years, the Treasury Officer shall address the Administrator of the Account in writing requiring him to show cause within one month why the balance in the account should not be credited to Revenue Deposits failing which, the Treasury Officer shall close the account and transfer the balance to Revenue Receipt Head 0075. As per existing accounting practice, amount brought back from the PD Account should be deduct debited to the service head from where the original transfers took place.
During the year 2024-25, 189 PD accounts having a total balance of ₹206.16 crore were inoperative for more than three years as of 31 March 2025. However, no action has been taken to close these accounts by the treasuries concerned. The details of inoperative Personal Deposit Accounts are given in Appendix 3.2.
Rule 355 of Madhya Pradesh Treasury Code volume-II states that the credit balance in the Personal Deposit Account maintained in the treasury should not be negative. It is necessary to make corrections by matching the figures with the records of the O/o AG (A&E). Audit noticed that out of 679 Personal Deposit Accounts, 114 PD accounts maintain in 38 treasuries have shown a negative balance of (-)₹ 2,324.55 crore. The details are given in Appendix 3.3.
The Minor Head 800-Other Expenditure/800-Other Receipts is to be operated only when the appropriate minor head has not been provided in the accounts. Routine operation of Minor Head 800 should be discouraged, since it renders the accounts opaque. Classification of large amounts under the omnibus Minor Head 800 affects transparency in financial reporting and distorts proper analysis of allocative priorities and quality of expenditure.
During the year 2024-25, ₹41,034.89 crore under 68 Major Heads of accounts, constituting 12.97 per cent of the total Revenue and Capital expenditure (₹3,16,366.17 crore) was classified under the Minor Head 800-Other Expenditure in the accounts. Out of this, specific Minor Heads have been identified that could have been used instead of Minor Head 800 to book expenditure of ₹5,789.23 crore (1.83 per cent of the total Revenue and Capital expenditure : ₹3,16,366.17 crore). The details are given in Table 3.12.
Instances where a substantial portion (50 per cent or more) of the total expenditure under the Major Head concerned of the expenditure have been classified under Minor Head 800-Other Expenditure are given in Table 3.13.
Similarly, ₹10,793.88 crore under 50 Major Heads of Account, constituting 4.31 per cent of the total Revenue Receipts (₹ 2,50,498.27 crore) was classified under 800-Other Receipts in the accounts.
Instances where a substantial portion (50 per cent or more) of the total receipts under the Major Head concerned of the receipts have been classified under Minor Head 800-Other Receipts are given in Table 3.14:
The Finance Accounts reflect the net balances under Suspense and Remittance Heads. The outstanding balances under these heads are worked out by aggregating the outstanding debit and credit balances under various heads. Significant suspense items balances for the last three years have been shown in Table 3.15:
non-clearance of outstanding balances under these heads affects the accuracy of receipt/expenditure figures and balances under different heads of Accounts (which are carried forward from year to year) of the State Government.
All Controlling Officers are required to reconcile the receipts and expenditure of the Government with the figures accounted for by the Accountant General (A&E). In Madhya Pradesh, instead of Budget Controlling Officers, Directorate of Treasuries and Accounts is primarily reconciling the figures with the A&E office.
During 2024-25, Directorate of Treasuries and Accounts has reconciled expenditure of ₹3,40,740.22 crore (98.50 per cent of the total expenditure under the Consolidated Fund ₹3,45,938.47 crore) and receipt of ₹3,42,475.05 crore (99.29 per cent of total receipts under the Consolidated Fund ₹3,44,919.59 crore). The status of reconciliation of receipts and expenditure figures during the last three-year period 2022-23 to 2024-25 is shown inTable 3.16 and Chart 3.3:
After the introduction of system of online reconciliation by the Directorate of Treasury and Accounts in July 2020, Audit observed that there have been significant improvements in the reconciliation process.
As per accounts of the Accountant General (A&E), the Cash Balance of the State Government as on 31 March 2025 was ₹400.37 crore (credit) while the same was reported as ₹198.74 crore (Debit) by the Reserve Bank of India. As such, there was an un-reconciled difference of ₹201.63 crore, which was under reconciliation between the Accountant General (A&E) and the State Government.
After integration of e-Kuber system (of the RBI) with State Integrated Financial Management System (IFMS) for payments in the State, the difference in reported transactions has increased as the State IFMS reports are on transaction date basis whereas the e-Kuber system reports the transactions on scroll date basis.
As per Codal provisions, funds received by Public Works Divisions towards Deposit Works from non-government agencies are required to be credited under Minor Head '108 - Public Works Deposits' below Major Head '8443-Civil Deposits'. The expenditure for related Deposit Works is also met from the same head of account. In the Monthly Divisional Accounts unremitted amount of such deposits are classified under Major Head '8671 -Departmental Balances, 101 - Civil', by the PW Divisions, under Public Account of the State and then form part of the Government Accounts. However, the funds received towards Deposits Works are being kept in the bank accounts of Divisional Officers operated by PW Divisions instead of remitting them into the Government Accounts and thus, are not forming part of cash balance of the State with Reserve Bank of India.
During the year 2024-25, the information pertaining to unspent amount lying with divisional officers was called from various departments of Govt. of Madhya Pradesh viz. PWD, PHE, NVDA, WRD and Finance Department, etc. However, only the Water Resourse Department furnished the information of the amounts lying in bank accounts being operated by Divisional Officers as detailed in Table 3.17.
As on 31 March 2025, out of seven Divisional officer 28 operating Bank Accounts, an amount of ₹0.26 crore was lying in the bank accounts (No. 42398113496) of Dy. Director Jal Mousam Vigyan Dn. No.-1 WRD Bhopal. Had the funds been deposited in the treasury, the same would have impacted on the daily Cash Balance of the State Government.
As per Article 150 of the Constitution of India, the President of India may, on the advice of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG), prescribe the form of accounts of the Union and of the States. On the advice of the CAG, the President of India has so far notified four Indian Government Accounting Standards (IGAS). Compliance to these Accounting Standards by the State Government as well as deficiencies therein during 2024-25, are detailed in Tabel 3.18.
As on 31 March 2025, 10 accounts in respect of six Autonomous Bodies (ABs) were pending from 2023-24 to 2024-25 as detailed in Table 3.19.
As the accounts of the above six autonomous bodies have not been received by O/o the Principal Accountants General (Audit-I and II) Madhya Pradesh, Audit did not form any opinion on their accounts during the year. Delay in finalisation of accounts carries the risk of financial irregularities, therefore, the accounts need to be finalised and submitted to Audit at the earliest.
Rule 22(1) of Madhya Pradesh Financial Code Vol.-I, provides that any loss of public money, caused by defalcation or otherwise, should be immediately reported to the Accountant General, even when such loss has been made good by the party responsible for it.
As on 31 March 2025, 3161 cases of misappropriation, losses, theft, etc. involving ₹40.24 crore were pending. The Department-wise break-up of pending cases are given in Table 3.20.
Out of the total 3161 cases, in respect of 1652 cases (₹14.26 crore), departmental action had been initiated but not finalized, while in 1384 cases (₹24.63 crore) departmental and criminal proceedings were pending.
The age-profile of the pending cases and the number of cases pending in each category-theft and misappropriation/loss of Government material is summarized in Table 3.21.
Out of the total cases, 195 cases amounting to ₹6.75 crore were related to theft of Government money/stores, and the remaining 2966 cases involving ₹33.49 crore were pertaining to misappropriation/loss of Government material, whereas 1415 cases involving ₹6.24 crore pertaining to misappropriation/loss of Government material were pending for more than 25 years.
In every State, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC)/Finance Department require the line Departments to provide suo-moto Explanatory Notes (EN) on the paragraphs featuring in the Audit Reports within one month of placing the Reports in the Legislature. The line Departments are also required to provide Action Taken Notes (ATNs) to the AG (for vetting and onward transmission to the PAC) within three months of tabling the Reports.
The discussion on the State Finances Audit Report for the year 2011-12 was held in 2018-19 wherein PAC had recommended regularisation regarding paragraph on excess expenditure requiring regularisation. However, regularisation was confirmed through a gazette notification published on 18 December 2025. The SFARs for the years 2019-20 and 2020-21 are yet to be discussed by the PAC. Further, a selection proposal of paragraph included in the Audit Reports for the years 2021-22 and 2022-23 has been submitted to the Public Accounts Committee for examination through oral evidence and written replies. The response from the Committee is awaited. The State Finances Audit Report for the year 2023-24 was tabled in the State Legislature on 31 July 2025.
Utilisation Certificates had not been submitted by various Departments for an aggregate amount of ₹60,113.33 crore drawn for specific developmental programmes/projects, which was violative of prescribed financial rules and directives, and points to inadequate internal controls, while reflecting poorly on the monitoring mechanism of the State Government.
As of 31 March 2025, 679 Personal Deposit Accounts were in existence and the closing balance in these accounts was ₹4,812.13 crore. Out of the total number of 679 PD accounts, 189 PD accounts having a total balance of ₹206.16 crore were inoperative for more than three years. The Government should have monitored these Accounts closely and ensured that such inoperative Accounts are closed and the balances transferred to Government Account in accordance with the Treasury Code of the State.
During the year 2024-25, ₹41,034.89 crore constituting 12.97 per cent of the total Revenue and Capital expenditure (₹3,16,366.17 crore) was classified under the Minor Head 800-Other Expenditure in the accounts. Similarly, ₹10,793.88 crore constituting 4.31 per cent of the total Revenue Receipts (₹2,50,498.27 crore) was classified under 800-Other Receipts in the accounts. Classification of large amounts under the omnibus Minor Head 800 affects transparency in financial reporting and distorts proper analysis of allocative priorities and quality of expenditure.
The reconciliation work of departmental figures with those booked by the Office of the Accountant General (A&E) has been initiated online by Directorate of Treasury and Accounts in July 2020 and accounts have been reconciled to the extent of 99.29 per cent in respect of receipts and 98.50 per cent in respect of expenditure.